• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Qualifying Event
  • Subsidies
  • Open Enrollment

Colorado Health Insurance Insider

No-cost broker assistance.

And You Thought Gender Based Pricing Was Bad

September 29, 2009 By Jay Norris

Colorado State Senator Morgan Carroll recently wrote an article about ending gender discrimination in health insurance premiums. Women are by default charged more for health insurance until the age of 55.  After age 55, men pay more.  Some argue that gender has an actuarial use though, because women under age 55 have more and higher claims than men.  The same goes for men over the age of 55.

Now, an insurance company called GuideOne Mutual actually had a question about “religious denomination.” And it seems that Atheists and Agnostics were charged more.

The Department of Justice sued GuideOne in federal court in Kentucky after receiving complaints about the insurer’s “FaithGuard” policy that offered homebuyers, owners and renters in 19 states special benefits and discounts if they were churchgoers.

The company has agreed to settle the lawsuit for $74,000. It also will stop asking policyholders to state their religious denomination on application forms, develop new, nondiscriminatory insurance deals, train its employees and agents on the Fair Housing Act, and report in periodically with Justice Department officials.

I wonder what kind of actuarial data they used to come up with that.

Related Posts:

  • Colorado Senator Morgan Carroll On Health Insurance
    Colorado Senator Morgan Carroll On Health Insurance
  • Gender, Age, Geography, and Health Insurance Premiums
    Gender, Age, Geography, and Health Insurance Premiums
  • Governor Ritter Signs Health Insurance Gender Discrimination Bill
    Governor Ritter Signs Health Insurance Gender…
  • Some Thoughts On Colorado HB1224
    Some Thoughts On Colorado HB1224
  • Colorado Legislative Sessions Opens With Health Insurance Reform Bills
    Colorado Legislative Sessions Opens With Health…
  • Health Insurance Premiums For Men And Women
    Health Insurance Premiums For Men And Women

Filed Under: Health Care Goodies, Health Insurance Reform, Insurance Companies, Policy

About Jay Norris

Jay operates a health insurance brokerage in Colorado, where he helps individuals and small groups obtain and maintain health insurance coverage, provides data analysis, and creates visualizations that are easily understood by consumers and other stakeholders in Colorado’s health insurance market.

Footer

Copyright © 2025 · Insurance Shoppers, Inc. · Privacy Policy